Card Grading Cost Comparison 2026

PSA vs BGS vs CGC vs SGC - full pricing comparison for 2026. CGC has the cheapest entry at $15/card. PSA requires a $99/year membership the others do not. BGS includes sub-grades free. SGC Turbo is the fastest major grader at $150 for 2-3 days.

All four companies compared on every dimension that matters: cost, turnaround, membership, sub-grades, and resale premiums.

Pre-Screen My Cards Free

All Four Graders Head-to-Head

Every major dimension compared across PSA, BGS, CGC, and SGC for 2026 submissions.

Feature CGC SGC BGS PSA
Entry price $15 $20 $25 $25 (+ $99 membership)
Standard tier $30/card $25/card $25/card $50/card
Annual membership None None None $99/year
10 cards all-in (budget, yr 1) $190 $290 $290 $389
10 cards all-in (budget, yr 2+) $190 $290 $290 $290
Sub-grades Optional (+$10) No Yes (free) No
Grading scale 1-10 10-100 1-10 (0.5 steps) 1-10
Fastest tier Same day ($250) 2-3 days ($150) Same day ($250) 1-2 days ($300)
Resale premium Growing, below PSA Lower than PSA Strong for pristine Highest
Best for Budget grading, sub-grade data Vintage sports, fast turnaround Pristine cards, sub-grades Resale value, Pokemon

Membership note: PSA is the only major grader that requires a paid annual membership ($99/year). CGC, SGC, and BGS all let you submit with a free account. For collectors who grade fewer than 20 cards per year, PSA's membership adds $5-$10 per card in overhead on top of the per-card grading fee.

Complete Tier Pricing by Company

Every service tier, cost, and turnaround time for all four major grading companies.

CGC

Membership: None

Tier Cost Turnaround
Economy $15 ~80 days
Standard $30 ~50 days
Express $75 ~15 days
Super Express $150 ~5 days
Walk-Through $250 Same day

SGC

Membership: None

Tier Cost Turnaround
Economy $20 ~180 days
Standard $25 45-60 days
Silver $50 15-20 days
Gold $75 5-10 days
Turbo $150 2-3 days

BGS

Membership: None

Tier Cost Turnaround
Standard $25 20-30 days
Express $50 5-10 days
Premium $100 2-3 days
Walk-Through $250 Same day

PSA

Membership: $99/year (includes $50 voucher)

Tier Cost Turnaround
Value $25 45-65 days
Regular $50 20-30 days
Express $75 10-15 days
Super Express $150 5 days
Walk-Through $300 1-2 days

The PSA Membership Math

PSA's $99/year membership includes a $50 voucher toward your first order. Here is how that changes the real cost depending on your submission volume.

Cards per year PSA membership add-on (per card) Verdict
1 card $49 net membership per card ($99 - $50 voucher) PSA is very expensive for one-off submissions
5 cards $9.80 per card net in year 1 Adds up; CGC likely cheaper total
20 cards $2.45 per card net in year 1 PSA premium may justify itself at this volume
50 cards $0.98 per card net in year 1 PSA membership is effectively free at this volume

Takeaway: PSA membership makes financial sense for collectors who submit 20+ cards per year. Below that threshold, CGC, SGC, or BGS is typically cheaper all-in even if PSA commands higher resale premiums. At 5-10 cards per year, run the math for your specific cards before defaulting to PSA.

Which Grader to Pick by Use Case

The right grader depends on what you are trying to accomplish. Here is the honest recommendation for each common scenario.

Grading Pokemon cards to sell

PSA

PSA 10 slabs sell for more than any other grader on Pokemon cards. The $99 membership pays for itself on any card worth over $100 raw.

Grading Pokemon cards for your collection

CGC

No membership fee, $15 Economy option, optional sub-grades. CGC is the cost-effective choice when resale is not the goal.

Grading vintage sports cards

PSA or SGC

PSA commands the highest premiums on vintage. SGC is respected for vintage and offers finer grade distinctions with the 10-100 scale.

Grading a genuinely pristine modern card

BGS

BGS Black Label 10 (all four sub-grades perfect) commands premiums above PSA 10 on pristine modern cards. If you have a real Black Label candidate, BGS is the ceiling.

Need the fastest possible turnaround

SGC Turbo or BGS Walk-Through

SGC Turbo is $150 for 2-3 days, faster than PSA Super Express ($150, 5 days). BGS Walk-Through and CGC Walk-Through are same-day at shows for $250.

Budget is the primary constraint

CGC Economy

CGC Economy at $15/card is the lowest entry price in the market. No membership required. Great for building a graded collection without breaking the bank.

Want sub-grade detail on every card

BGS

BGS includes centering, corners, edges, and surface scores at no extra cost. CGC charges $10 extra for sub-grades and PSA does not offer them at all.

Fewer than 10 cards per year

CGC or SGC

PSA membership adds $99/year overhead. CGC and SGC have no membership. For casual submitters, avoiding the membership saves more money than PSA's resale premium earns.

All-In Cost Examples for 10 Cards

Real total cost for a 10-card submission at the budget tier for each grader, including shipping and membership where applicable.

CGC Economy (10 cards)

Grading: 10 x $15 = $150

Shipping: $20 + $20 return = $40

Membership: $0

$190 total

$19/card all-in

SGC Standard (10 cards)

Grading: 10 x $25 = $250

Shipping: $20 + $20 return = $40

Membership: $0

$290 total

$29/card all-in

BGS Standard (10 cards)

Grading: 10 x $25 = $250 (sub-grades included)

Shipping: $20 + $20 return = $40

Membership: $0

$290 total

$29/card all-in, sub-grades included

PSA Value (10 cards, year 1)

Grading: 10 x $25 = $250

Shipping: $20 + $20 return = $40

Membership (net): $99 - $50 voucher = $49

$339 total

$33.90/card all-in (year one)

Smart move before any submission: Pre-screen your 10 cards with CardGrading.app for $3.49 before deciding which grader and tier to use. Knowing which cards are likely to grade well helps you choose the right service level - and filter out the ones that will not pay off at any grader.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about card grading costs and how to choose between PSA, BGS, CGC, and SGC.

Which card grading company is cheapest in 2026?
CGC is cheapest at the entry level with Economy grading at $15/card and no membership required. At the standard tier, SGC and BGS both start at $25/card versus PSA at $50/card (Regular). PSA also requires a $99/year membership, making it the most expensive option overall for small submission volumes. For a 10-card submission in year one, CGC is roughly $200 cheaper than PSA all-in.

Which grading company has the fastest turnaround?
SGC Turbo is the fastest mainstream option at 2-3 business days for $150. PSA Super Express at $150 takes 5 days. BGS Walk-Through, CGC Walk-Through, and PSA Walk-Through all offer same-day to 1-2 day service at shows, but Walk-Through grading requires attending a show in person or costs $250-$300. For mail submissions, SGC Turbo is the speed leader at the $150 price point.

Which grader gives the highest resale value?
PSA commands the highest resale premiums for most card types, especially Pokemon and mainstream sports cards. PSA 10 slabs sell for more than CGC 10, BGS 9.5, or SGC 100 equivalents on popular cards. The exception is BGS Black Label 10 (all four sub-grades perfect), which can exceed PSA 10 on truly pristine modern cards. For vintage sports, PSA and SGC are close, with PSA still leading on most pre-war and 1950s cards.

Do PSA, CGC, BGS, and SGC all grade the same way?
All four evaluate the same four criteria: centering, corners, edges, and surface. However, they use different scales (PSA, CGC: 1-10; BGS: 1-10 with 0.5 increments; SGC: 10-100), and their grading stringency differs. BGS is generally considered the strictest grader, especially on centering. CGC and PSA use similar standards on most criteria. SGC's 10-100 scale offers finer distinctions in the near-mint range. A PSA 9 does not automatically equal a CGC 9 on the same card.

Is there a membership fee for BGS grading?
No, BGS (Beckett Grading Services) does not require an annual membership fee. You create a free account on Beckett's website and submit when you have cards ready. This is the same as CGC and SGC. Only PSA charges a mandatory annual membership fee ($99/year).

How do I decide which grader to use?
Start with your goal. If you plan to sell the graded card, PSA is the default choice for most card types due to higher resale premiums. If you are grading for your personal collection or to document condition, CGC is the most cost-effective option with no membership fee. If you have a genuinely pristine card you want to maximize, consider BGS for the Black Label 10 potential. If you need cards graded quickly without PSA prices, SGC Turbo is worth considering. Pre-screen with CardGrading.app before any submission to identify your strongest candidates.

Individual Grader Deep Dives

PSA Grading Cost 2026

Full tier breakdown, $99 membership math, hidden fees, and AI pre-screening savings.

Beckett Grading Cost 2026

BGS pricing, sub-grades included free, Black Label potential, and when BGS beats PSA.

CGC Grading Cost 2026

CGC tiers from $15 Economy, no membership, optional sub-grades, and when to use CGC.

SGC Grading Cost 2026

SGC tiers, Turbo 2-3 day speed, the 10-100 scale, and vintage card expertise.

PSA vs CGC 2026

Head-to-head on cost, resale premium, sub-grades, and which to pick for your situation.

PSA vs Beckett 2026

PSA vs BGS on resale premiums, sub-grades, Black Label, and which wins for your cards.

Pre-Screen Before You Pick a Grader

Know what your cards are likely to grade before spending $15 to $300 per card. Snap a photo, get an AI prediction in 30 seconds. Start with 3 free scans.

Pre-Screen My Cards

3 free scans · No credit card required · Cancel anytime